Showing posts with label Accountability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Accountability. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 30, 2014

The Sword of Damocles, Redux

It has been some time (two years) since I last posted in this forum.  I wanted to share comments published recently in the POMA Newsletter.


The title of April’s Another Voice, “ACGME Sword of Damocles Poised to Strike a Devastating Blow”(POMA Newsletter, April 10, 2014), well describes the current state for osteopathic graduate medical education (OGME), but not for the reasons the author intends.  Please see the link to the meaning of the legend of Damocles’ sword.

One reason for my support for moving to a unified accreditation system is that the OGME system currently exists in a state “of foreboding engendered by a precarious situation, especially one in which the onset of tragedy is restrained only by a delicate trigger or chance.”  In the current state, multiple swords hang over OGME.  These include:  graduate medical education (GME) financing, governance of OGME by a membership organization, lack of reliability, relevance to graduates of colleges of osteopathic medicine (COM), lack of positions for future COM graduates, and yes, the actions of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME), who is the provider of the majority of GME for COM graduates.  A unified system removes many of these swords hanging “from a single horse hair” above the head of OGME.  Other swords may remain, but they are better tethered.  I’m confident that these can be removed by the future educational leadership of the osteopathic profession having a governance stake in GME within the United States.

Reliance on the status quo leaves all swords hanging over OGME’s head.  While I do not possess a crystal ball, I believe that one or more of the noted swords will fall within the not-too-distant future.  This would result in a GME system where the osteopathic profession has no governance stake.  If that happens, there will be no opportunity to teach osteopathic philosophy.  This would guarantee the fulfillment of Still’s admonition:  “unless you teach, neither you, nor osteopathic medicine will survive.”

It is a false interpretation that a unified system with shared governance precludes teaching osteopathic philosophy and tenets.  In fact, the unified system perpetuates osteopathic principles by explicitly including them in the accreditation standards.  One has to ask themselves:  is it more likely to have osteopathic philosophy taught in a system where the osteopathic profession shares a governance stake or a system where the osteopathic profession has no governance stake?  I recognize that all do not share my concern for the swords hanging over our heads which are “poised to strike a devastating blow.”  They would say that the status quo is acceptable and a full governance stake in a fraction of GME is preferable to shared governance of entire United States GME system.  I addressed this topic in the April JAOA.

The professional exploration of this topic is quite valuable.  The scientific method stipulates that the first step in any evaluation is to define the question.  This question is not the worth of osteopathic values.  The question is:  what is the most likely path to ensure that those values continue to be taught?  The evidence points to a unified system of GME accreditation being the answer.

Originally published in the POMA Newsletter, April 25, 2014

Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Everything flows...nothing stands still...the final installment

I know that you have all been on the edge of your seat for part 3, so without further adieu, here it is, the last facet, organizational flows…
·         The AODME is in the midst of a strategic planning process.  This has entailed using proven methodology to flesh out our goals and aspirations as an organization.  The board held a planning retreat in July (in conjunction with the AOA House of Delegates) and there were surveys of membership before and after this retreat.  One large move is the decision to focus on excellence in Clinical Osteopathic Medical Education.  This includes the undergraduate, graduate and continuing medical education spheres, with an emphasis on OGME.
·         As many of you know, the AODME has purchased management services from the AOA since 2003.  This contract has been automatically renewable on a yearly basis.  The AODME shares a close working, teamwork relationship with the AOA and recently had Susan Sevensma, DO appointed as the liaison from the AOA Board to the AODME Board.  This is a first for both organizations.
·         Finally, the AODME underwent a by-laws change in December of 2011.  This change culminated four years of discussion on the topic, through three annual meetings, multiple surveys and drafts of the changes.  The by-laws were ratified by a 90% positive vote of two thirds of the members.  This was not small accomplishment for a small and diverse organization.  The changes brought the AODME in line with the current structure of OGME, including the realization that most DMEs commune as OPTIs.
Everything flows…nothing stands still.  The AODME and OGME are certainly proof of this.

Monday, December 5, 2011

AODME By-laws changes...

As the members of the AODME know, an update to the organization's by-laws are now out to the membership for a vote.  This is the culmination of a two year process that is aimed at aligning the by-laws of the AODME with the realities that currently exist in OGME.

The key changes are:
  1. The executive committee terms move from two to one year and the position of immediate past president is added.  This reflects a desire to have more members be involved in the executive leadership of the organization.  Currently, there are 5 positions (Secretary, Treasurer, President-elect, President and Past-president) with two year terms.  This limits the elections to odd numbered years and results in 10 years on the executive committee.  The change would have a 6 member executive committee with yearly elections and 6 years on the committee.  The addition of immediate past president (or past president depending on one's perspective) was sought to lend institutional memory to the board.
  2. Removal of 4 sub-category (OPTI, COM, Specialty College and Hospital) trustees.  These positions have been difficult to define since their inception and do not serve a constituency.
  3. The addition of OPTI Council Appointed Trustees.  As has been noted at the last several meetings, the AODME, the AODME is seeking to work with OPTIs and the DMEs that comprise OPTIs to provide a advocacy and educational voice for this significant cog in the OGME machine.  This change recognizes that DMEs are aligned as much with OPTIs as they are with regions and allows for a blend of leadership.  OPTI Council Appointed Trustees must maintain the same membership requirements as regional trustees.
  4. Changes to terms of of trustees from three to two years.  The overall limit would remain 6 years.  This change also allows more members to have the opportunity to be members of the board.
  5. Re-distribution of the AODME's regions to represent the current make-up of OGME.
  6. Codification of governance items such as quorums, committees and special meetings.  In each case, the bar was set to allow inclusion and representative participation.
Many members worked hard to bring this to fruition.  This includes both members of the executive committee, board and rank and file members from all regions and backgrounds.  This process began in 2009 and there have been multiple avenues for comment and evolution.  This includes, but is not limited to:
  • Both the 2010 and 2011 Annual meetings
  • Email appeals in the Fall of 2010 and 2011
  • Multiple surveys of membership
I set a goal to move the organization forward.  I do not expect all to agree on what this means.  I do expect to be transparent and build consensus.  I am comfortable that we have accomplished both with these proposed changes.

Part of this goal is a up or down vote on the by-laws change.  It is time to fish or cut bait.  While no proposal will be perfect, this is a good, team approach.  Regardless of your view, it is important to participate in this endeavor.  I appreciate the collegial and professional debate.

Friday, August 19, 2011

Proposed Standards changes up for comment

Follow-up is now available from a previous post on vigilance and the comment period for new standards.  Earlier this month (in the last week or two) the standards approved at the July Council of Postdoctoral Training meeting were posted.  The can be found on the AOA's web site at this link.

There is also a link to the email address where comments should be directed.  This is:  Postdoc@osteopathic.org

The comment period is 45 days - so this should be around the end of September.

There are substantive changes in the Osteopathic Postdoctoral Training Institution standards up for comment.  These implement policy changes that have been discussed at multiple forums.There are also re-writes of many specialty standards.

This is the opportunity for the osteopathic graduate medical educators to be part of the process.
All are encouraged to comment!

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

I'm so tired, I haven't slept a wink...Duty hours and OGME

July 1, 2011 brought new duty hours rules to OGME programs and their ACGME counterparts.  This has led to a significant number of commentaries in the print media (LA Times, NY Times) and on-line in the blogosphere.

It is a common sense (I realize that this is not "common") given that less long hours is a satisfier for trainees.  I cannot blame them.  While I trained in the halcyon days of 48 hour shifts and minimal supervision, I consider myself wise enough to see the error in those ways.  I do not remember enjoying any part of that experience.

I think that there is adequate evidence that less sleep to less cognition.  Poorer quality of cognition leads to gaps in patients' care.  Patient care gaps are bad. 

I am also a pragmatist and realize that duty hours rules are not going away.  I also am aware that there are those who feel that they do not go far enough.

Given this reality, what are some of the other unintended consequences of this paradigm shift?  Here are a few:

1.      If the current residents are not going to be around to care for the patients, who will?  This is a significant policy question.  The call for 24/7 coverage of hospitals compounds this reality.  A recent blog post by Brad Flansbaum, DO for the Society of Hospital Medicine elucidates more issues on this topic.
2.      While the QUALITY of education rises with a higher level of cognition, the decrease in hours (and in many instances census) decreases the QUANTITY of education.  This may not be all bad as there is some evidence that our current quantity paradigms are flawed.  In a competency-based world it is outcomes that matter, not time served.  The problem is that we are “not there” yet.  There is also a suggestion, both anecdotal and some evidence that time (likely maturity) may matter.
3.      See #1 and #2…If we need more physicians to care for the patients and if those physicians are trained in a paradigm of decreasing workload (hours and volume), then we will need even more physicians.  It is a self-perpetuating cycle.

While I do not have the answers to solve this problem, we need to look at #2 for answers.  What is the needed education?  What does the physician of the future need to know and how to we train this in the new paradigm?  Who are our partners on the healthcare team and how can they help solve this dilemma?

Some of solutions are beginning to be developed.  We have discussed some of them in past posts.  We need to change what, when and how we teach.

We need to train thought not facts.

We need to train leaders not managers.

We need to communicators not commanders.

The solutions will require open minds and innovation. 

Rest assured there is no turning back!

Wednesday, July 27, 2011

July Education Cluster - Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty.

In the middle of the heat wave, the July education cluster meetings took place last week, both in person and virtually.

For those of you not familiar with these meetings, they generally occur in Chicago at the O'Hare Hilton.  Many people ask me "How was the weather in Chicago?"  My general response is that "I have no idea!"  Chicago is a misnomer in this case as the Hilton and the airport is connected by a tunnel and after I walk into the airport in Wilkes-Barre I don't feel the outside air until I return to Wilkes-Barre.

The Council on Osteopathic Postgraduate Training Institutions (COPTI) met by phone on Wednesday.  There was an active discussion and subsequent approval of new OPTI standards.  COPTI also discussed a new approval paradigm for OPTIs.  This would create a process much like hospitals and colleges of osteopathic medicine where fully accredited OPTIs have a five year approval.  It also includes interim monitoring rubrics on a regular basis.

The Program and Trainee Review Council (PTRC) met on Thursday.  Hospitals, OPTIs and Specialty College Evaluating committees (SPECs) collaborated on accreditation decisions on 71 OGME programs.  The PTRC also discussed the inspection protocols for Emergency Medicine, Family Medicine, Internal Medicine and General Surgery programs.  As of July 1, these specialties have "new" accreditation standards.  These standards are devoid of institutional standards as the future plan is to review this as part of to-be-implemented institutional review.  A hybrid approach will be used employing the specialty crosswalk and a modified institutional crosswalk.  A multi-specialty team developed this approach.

Finally, the Council on Postdoctoral Training (COPT) met on Friday and Saturday.  The bulk of this meeting encompassed approval of another round of "new" specialty Basic Standards.  SPECs and the COPT have done yoemans work over the last 12 months to re-write, edit and approve these standards.  The COPT also addressed several other policy issues involved with OGME.

It is also worth noting that all COPT actions will be available for public comment.  Those comments must then be addressed by COPT.  This includes all the specialty college standards and OPTI standards.  A programing note...the current standards on this link are from the April COPT meeting.  (UPDATE:  old standards removed July 29, 2011)

blOGME will do its best to alert the OGME community of the opportunity to comment.  The suggestion is not that everything needs changed or comment.  By the same token, we should no longer hear "How did that happen?" 

Transparency is here!

Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty!  It is up to the OGME community to accept the challenge of keeping vigil.

Friday, July 8, 2011

Accountable Osteopathic Educational Organizations - AOEOs coming to a hospital near you!

So the buzz in the health care community right now is Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs).  The concept is an entity that is accountable for the care of populations of patients.  This entity encompasses hospitals, physicians, care management entities, home care, dialysis centers, etc., etc., etc.  The overarching goal is that there is improved value (quality and cost) to the patient.  There are multiple entities that are mentioned as shining examples of this model.  Critics proclaim that this cannot be done broadly and that we should not even try.

Apart from, yet concomitant with this trend is the discussions in Washington about accountability in graduate medical education.  This is coming, maybe sooner than we think.

Students of the game are well aware of the MedPAC report on the subject of accountability of Indirect Graduate Medical Education (IME) dollars.  There was a New England Journal Opinion piece from MedPAC on the same topic.  In addition, there was a front page article today in the Boston Globe discussing both decreases in GME funding from the Federal government and the lack of accountability in the current system.

What will accountability mean?  It is any one's guess, but if I had to read the tea leaves I would start at the Quality Compare web site mentioned in a previous post.  The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has laid the groundwork for what it sees as transparency here.  It has also given a glimpse of the clinical metrics that it intends to use in the future in recent rules and proposed rules regarding Value-Based Purchasing (VBP).  The OGME world can expect educational metrics in the not-so-distant future.

Specifically, expect to see:  program size, program retention, board pass rates, graduates that practice in under served areas, graduates that practice within 25 miles of the training site, graduates of internal medicine and pediatrics programs that practice primary care.

Secondary, one may see:  does the hospital have an EHR, how much of the training is ambulatory, what are the procedure rates when applicable, is there training directly with other types of providers?

A next level may be:  continuous certification results for graduates, VBP results like HbA1C, LDL cholesterol, ACE inhibitors for CHF, etc. for graduates, state board of medicine actions for graduates.  Maybe I'm stretching, maybe I'm not.  If you were looking for a doctor, wouldn't you want to know how the program where he trained performs.  And by performs, you wouldn't really care how big the library is...would you??

The list is endless.  VBP is approaching 100 inpatient and outpatient measures, so, while I am being provocative, I am not wildly outside the box.

One additional note is that most of the VBP metrics have been vetted by and endorsed by the National Quality Forum.  There have been calls for a similar group for GME metrics.  It will be critical that OGME is represented at that table.

Change is coming!  It will make the present discussions look quite petty.  Are we ready??