Showing posts with label Macy Foundation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Macy Foundation. Show all posts

Saturday, November 26, 2011

Thanksgiving, a time for reflection.

It seems that for many, Thanksgiving is a time for reflection.  There are many things, some personal - some collective, for which to give thanks.  In the spirit of reflection, I'd like to give some updates on past posts and see where we are now in the OGME worlds.

It has been some time since my last post!  I was hit by the confluence of MBA residency, two sons and a daughter headed back to school and the realities of a turn in my professional life.  But, enough about me...I'm back for now!

In an earlier post, I noted that there were a multitude of AOA standard's changes up for comment.  These included the changes to the standards for Osteopathic Postgraduate Training Institutions (OPTIs).  This were subsequently approved by the AOA's Council on Postgraduate Training (COPT) at their November meeting.  There, for better or for worse, were few comments.  While I'm sure that some will come back and wonder the who, why, when and where of these standards changes, little can be said about the transparency of the process.

I have noted several times that I participated in a conference on the future of graduate medical education in the United States in May.  This was sponsored by the Macy Foundation.  The report from this conference was published online and the monograph has been printed.  There has been quite a bit of discussion in both the lay press and the medical media on this report.  The Federal government's Council on Graduate Medical Education discussed this at their most recent meeting.

In October the ACGME published proposed changes to their Common Program Requirements.  The changes would require ACGME (or Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada) accredited training as a prerequisite for further ACGME training.  This would significant alter several ACGME residency programs' practices, such as Family Medicine, Radiology and Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation residencies.  It would also significantly impact fellowships in several specialties.

These changes have several potential unintended consequences to GME and physician workforce.  There are also several direct consequences to osteopathic trainees.  The changes included an impact statement that tangentially questioned the veracity of AOA accreditation of GME.  The AODME along with the AOA and AACOM submitted comments on the proposed changes.  Many other organizations, both within and outside the osteopathic community also commented on the proposals negative impact on osteopathic physicians.  We all eagerly await the outcome.

As the end of the year holidays come upon us, the AODME has published for approval changes to the organization's by-laws.  These changes, which I will discuss in a subsequent post, aim to update the by-laws and the AODME to be in line with the current realities of OGME.

Finally, in a weekend of thanks, I am thankful most for my family.  Thanksgiving weekend is always a joy to spend time with my immediate and extended family.  I am especially thankful for Ava, Ben, Ethan and Michele!  They keep me going through thick and thin!

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

What kind of work?? TEAMWORK!!

For those of you with young children, you may recognize the title as a catchy (sometimes so catchy that one can't get it out of their head) theme song for Nick Jr.'s Wonderpets.  Every time I hear the song (and I hear it frequently) I cannot help but think of Karen Nichols, DO's (current President of the American Osteopathic Association) them for this year of TEAMWORK.

Teamwork is essential to the delivery of quality medical care.  Given this, teaching and mentoring teamwork is also essential for OGME.

I played on Juniata College's baseball team many years ago (glory days alert).    Baseball has 9 players on the field at a given time and a successful team has many pitchers and non-starters that contribute.  My college baseball team had arguably (I may be biased) the most successful three year stretch in the schools history.  There was only one player on those TEAMs who I would label a star (and it wasn't me).  We were successful because we were a cohesive team.

Medical care is much the same.  High quality care in the 21st Century is delivered best by a health care team.  These teams are not one-size-fits all.  Physicians need to be members of these teams, but may not lead every aspect of these teams...but...physicians need to be leaders.

To be leaders, physicians need to understand team dynamics.  To be leaders, physicians need to understand the perspectives of other members of the team (advanced practitioners, nurses, care managers, physical therapists, social workers, etc.).  To be leaders, physicians need to be able to effectively communicate.

So, do we teach all of this in our OGME programs?

The honest answer in my view has to be:  No, not very well...yet.  At the yet is the takeaway from this post.

A recent monograph from the Josiah Macy Foundation on Intraprofessional Education give a good road map of how to achieve yet.  The topic of teamwork was also the foundation of the recent AODME/AACOM meeting in Baltimore.

Our current Basic Standards for residency training do not promote teamwork and intraprofessional training as much as they should, but they also do no inhibit programs from innovating.  The former needs to be bolstered.

It should not be possible for future residents to graduate from our programs without having both training and experience with working in health care teams.  They should also have explicit opportunities to lead health care teams.  We also need to look for opportunities to leverage intraprofessional relationships that exist within some of our Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine to learn side-by-side with other professionals.

My personal sentinel model of health care was a brilliant team.  It was a "womb to tomb" primary care physician and his wife.  Together they were doctor, nurse, pharmacist, counselor, receptionist, secretary and office assistant.  Other than the first two roles they shared almost everything else.  That TEAMWORK provided excellent medical care for 40+ years.  That team was my grandparents.  Our patients need more relationships like this.

TEAMWORK needs to be one focus for OGME in the future.  TEAMWORK requires both give and take - and this will likely be one large challenge as we move forward, but our patients will demand the quality of care that only TEAMWORK can provide.

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

The gorilla in the room and what are we going to do about it!?!

Last night I presented a consultant training webinar for the AOA’s Bureau of OGME Development.   Check out the link if you are interested.  One of the astute questions (and I’m paraphrasing) was: 
What is the AOA going to do about GME when the American Association of Medical Colleges (AAMC, organization of MD schools, organization of schools that are accredited by the Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME) – the accrediting body for MD schools) just announced that their numbers of graduates will be up 27.6% by 2015?  (Adding the DO graduate increase will bring that total to 35%)
This is the gorilla in the room!!
The short, analytical answer is:  barring significant paradigm shifts, the numbers do not and will not compute.  One can sugar coat this problem as much as they like, but without significant change, 1 + 1 will not equal 10.
This is why I think that change will happen…shortly.  This is also why I think that it is critically important that we stop living in the OGME past.  There are many calls for reform out there (COGME, Macy, ACP).  We pride ourselves on being nimble and efficient.  Do we have the vision (and the drive) to heed these calls and change?
Some of the most obvious change targets which I will discuss over the next several weeks are:
·         Providing training where patients receive their care.
·         Encouraging team-based training in our residency programs.
·         Changing the national financing structure of OGME.
·         Looking to alternative institution sponsorship of programs (not to be confused with academic sponsorship).
Who will we lead this change? 
There will be a new generation of leaders in OGME (and I am in no way suggesting that I am one of them).  There are currently around 78,000 DOs in the United States.  There are over 18,000 students enrolled in our schools.  One doesn’t need Excel to do the math.  The tipping point is near.  This is not a doomsday prediction and don’t even believe that this is hyperbole.
I would suggest that our biggest problem right now is that an OGME educator farm system does not exist.  Even worse (yes another sporting world analogy) we do not have any bench strength.  This is what keeps me up at night!
Almost all know the oft quoted warning from George Santayana’s The Life of Reason:  “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”  This is sometimes used to suggest that absolute change is good and the past was bad.  The overlooked preceding lines state:  “Progress, far from consisting in change, depends on retentiveness. When change is absolute there remains no being to improve and no direction is set for possible improvement: and when experience is not retained, as among savages, infancy is perpetual.”
The leaders of the future remain to be seen.  Our institutional memory will be important to osteopathic medicine’s future.  It behooves those of us that were or are currently in leadership positions to CONSTRUCTIVELY (my purposeful emphasis) recruit and mentor these new leaders, help them with the history and not handicap them with the current “toolbox.”  One important role for the AODME moving forward is nurturing future OGME leaders.

Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Macy Foundation

I'm in Atlanta (with Bob Cain, DO) attending the Macy Foundation conference on Reforming Graduate Medical Education to Meet the Needs of the Public.  This meeting follows a Macy sponsored conference in October entitled:  Recommendations for an Accountable Graduate Medical Education System.

For those or you who are students of GME history and GME reform, you will know that the Macy Foundation has sponsored conferences on Medical Education many times in the past.  These can be found on their web site.  If you are interested in further historical perspective, consider reading the works of Kenneth Ludmerer, MD, one of the conference participants.

There are many significant issues facing GME and specifically OGME.  It is critical, now more than ever, that we keep our focus on our customers - the public - as we shape OGME policy.