Showing posts with label Physician shortage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Physician shortage. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

I'm so tired, I haven't slept a wink...Duty hours and OGME

July 1, 2011 brought new duty hours rules to OGME programs and their ACGME counterparts.  This has led to a significant number of commentaries in the print media (LA Times, NY Times) and on-line in the blogosphere.

It is a common sense (I realize that this is not "common") given that less long hours is a satisfier for trainees.  I cannot blame them.  While I trained in the halcyon days of 48 hour shifts and minimal supervision, I consider myself wise enough to see the error in those ways.  I do not remember enjoying any part of that experience.

I think that there is adequate evidence that less sleep to less cognition.  Poorer quality of cognition leads to gaps in patients' care.  Patient care gaps are bad. 

I am also a pragmatist and realize that duty hours rules are not going away.  I also am aware that there are those who feel that they do not go far enough.

Given this reality, what are some of the other unintended consequences of this paradigm shift?  Here are a few:

1.      If the current residents are not going to be around to care for the patients, who will?  This is a significant policy question.  The call for 24/7 coverage of hospitals compounds this reality.  A recent blog post by Brad Flansbaum, DO for the Society of Hospital Medicine elucidates more issues on this topic.
2.      While the QUALITY of education rises with a higher level of cognition, the decrease in hours (and in many instances census) decreases the QUANTITY of education.  This may not be all bad as there is some evidence that our current quantity paradigms are flawed.  In a competency-based world it is outcomes that matter, not time served.  The problem is that we are “not there” yet.  There is also a suggestion, both anecdotal and some evidence that time (likely maturity) may matter.
3.      See #1 and #2…If we need more physicians to care for the patients and if those physicians are trained in a paradigm of decreasing workload (hours and volume), then we will need even more physicians.  It is a self-perpetuating cycle.

While I do not have the answers to solve this problem, we need to look at #2 for answers.  What is the needed education?  What does the physician of the future need to know and how to we train this in the new paradigm?  Who are our partners on the healthcare team and how can they help solve this dilemma?

Some of solutions are beginning to be developed.  We have discussed some of them in past posts.  We need to change what, when and how we teach.

We need to train thought not facts.

We need to train leaders not managers.

We need to communicators not commanders.

The solutions will require open minds and innovation. 

Rest assured there is no turning back!

Friday, July 8, 2011

Accountable Osteopathic Educational Organizations - AOEOs coming to a hospital near you!

So the buzz in the health care community right now is Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs).  The concept is an entity that is accountable for the care of populations of patients.  This entity encompasses hospitals, physicians, care management entities, home care, dialysis centers, etc., etc., etc.  The overarching goal is that there is improved value (quality and cost) to the patient.  There are multiple entities that are mentioned as shining examples of this model.  Critics proclaim that this cannot be done broadly and that we should not even try.

Apart from, yet concomitant with this trend is the discussions in Washington about accountability in graduate medical education.  This is coming, maybe sooner than we think.

Students of the game are well aware of the MedPAC report on the subject of accountability of Indirect Graduate Medical Education (IME) dollars.  There was a New England Journal Opinion piece from MedPAC on the same topic.  In addition, there was a front page article today in the Boston Globe discussing both decreases in GME funding from the Federal government and the lack of accountability in the current system.

What will accountability mean?  It is any one's guess, but if I had to read the tea leaves I would start at the Quality Compare web site mentioned in a previous post.  The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has laid the groundwork for what it sees as transparency here.  It has also given a glimpse of the clinical metrics that it intends to use in the future in recent rules and proposed rules regarding Value-Based Purchasing (VBP).  The OGME world can expect educational metrics in the not-so-distant future.

Specifically, expect to see:  program size, program retention, board pass rates, graduates that practice in under served areas, graduates that practice within 25 miles of the training site, graduates of internal medicine and pediatrics programs that practice primary care.

Secondary, one may see:  does the hospital have an EHR, how much of the training is ambulatory, what are the procedure rates when applicable, is there training directly with other types of providers?

A next level may be:  continuous certification results for graduates, VBP results like HbA1C, LDL cholesterol, ACE inhibitors for CHF, etc. for graduates, state board of medicine actions for graduates.  Maybe I'm stretching, maybe I'm not.  If you were looking for a doctor, wouldn't you want to know how the program where he trained performs.  And by performs, you wouldn't really care how big the library is...would you??

The list is endless.  VBP is approaching 100 inpatient and outpatient measures, so, while I am being provocative, I am not wildly outside the box.

One additional note is that most of the VBP metrics have been vetted by and endorsed by the National Quality Forum.  There have been calls for a similar group for GME metrics.  It will be critical that OGME is represented at that table.

Change is coming!  It will make the present discussions look quite petty.  Are we ready??

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

Expanding OGME - Shared Resources ... Shared Responsibility

There was an interesting article in the New York Times on June 17th that discusses Medicare’s claim that CT scanning is overused in many of the nation’s hospitals.  This was especially apparent in non-academic centers.  “Double scanning” means ordering both a contrast and non-contrast scan of the same body part on the same patient.  This is part of Medicare's new "use of medical imaging core measures" on their Hospital Compare site.
Also of interest was the fact that, as with most Medicare data, there were wide disparities both locally and nationally.  For instance, the rate of “double scanning” was only 1% in Massachusetts and was 13% in Oklahoma.
So what does this have to do with OGME you ask??
Well, if one follows the link to the article, they will see that there is a wonderful interactive map attached.  While this map is intended to give the viewer an idea of the CT problem spots, it also provides a wonderful interactive look at ever hospital in the United States that does CT scans (and every hospital in the US that sponsors OGME).  A quick glance and the reader will note that most of those hospitals are on the East Coast.  The reader will also note that there are relatively fewer West of the Mississippi.
Much like OGME programs…
Much like ACGME programs…
The geographic misdistribution of AOA accredited OGME programs is a real problem that gains much air time in educational debates.  There is an excellent map showing this data published in the recent education edition of the JAOA. 
As noted, this is not unique to OGME.  When I ran the data in 2006, the distribution of OGME shared significant correlations with both US population and ACGME programs by state (California and Texas being the glaring exceptions).  While I have not run the data recently, I see no reason to suggest that this has changed in a negative way.
I want to be clear – I’m not suggesting that there is not an OGME distribution problem.  There are clearly issues in the West and some of the South.  There are also discrepancies in New England as well, but we rarely here about this.  I make the comment because I believe that we should resist the temptation to focus only on areas of perceived need.  When we worry about the size of the slices of pie, we simply get in our own way and do not move forward to accomplish our ultimate goal - making the OGME pie bigger.
The solution is to build programs – anywhere that we can build them – anytime we can build them.
It seems synergistic to build these programs in areas that are geographically contiguous with our Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine, but … we need programs anywhere that we can make them happen. 
It seems to make sense to have Osteopathic Postgraduate Training Institutions (OPTIs) involved in building programs – many have done a superb job – but … we can’t afford to limit our scope to just OPTI generated growth.
Maybe we should look to virgin hospitals (those without any current GME)?  Maybe we should look to dual accredit programs that are already ACGME accredited?  Maybe we should look to alternative sites like Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHC)?  The answers to these questions??  YES, YES and YES!!
Should we build specialty programs or primary care programs?  I think that by now you know my opinion...
To increase the size of the OGME pie – our ultimate goal to train our COM grads and provide value to the public – we cannot be parochial in our means to meet the end.  Any time, any where and by anyone.  In the words of Harry Truman:  It is amazing what you can accomplish when you do not care who gets the credit.