The answer is likely not right or wrong. This is the conundrum of patient safety. It is multifaceted. Fixing one thing in isolation may do little. In addition, "fixing" may actually make things worse because of the unintended consequences of the fix.
There are several areas that are great examples of this: duty hours rules and the electronic health record (EHR).
First, a little more on the complexity of patient safety. If it was easy, there wouldn't be a problem. There wouldn't be a Quality Chasm to cross.
One of the better visual schema on medical errors is the Swiss cheese model. This was formulated in England by James Reason. The logic is that we have many fail safes in medicine to keep errors from occurring. Each process is like a slice of Swiss cheese - each has many holes. When the processes are put together - like a block of Swiss cheese - the holes do not line up and all is well. But, every now and then, the holes line up and bad things happen.
Near misses? The hole went almost all the way through, but one or more slices saved the day - maybe a timeout in surgery or a second nurse double checking the label on a bag of blood.
Think of trainees cognitive ability like a slice of Swiss cheese. Pretty solid, but some holes. The duty hours changes made the holes that represented sleepy, cognitively impaired trainees smaller. But they still make mistakes (holes).
The changes opened up big holes on other slices, namely situational awareness. This lack of situational awareness happened because there was a hand-off. This hand-off is generally poorly done. This was an unintended consequence. This is why the changes didn't improve patient safety.
We need to do a better job teaching and standardizing hand-offs!
We can do this - check out several publications and presentations by Vineet Arora. You can also check out her blog. In one recent publication she and colleagues showed that pediatrics interns only handed-off topics well 2/3 of the time - at best. It was about a third for knowledge items. In spite of this, they generally thought they were doing well.
The electronic health record is another mystifier. Again, it seems to make perfect sense that having a legible record that is readily available, and can offer some decision support, should make care safer. But...we all know that there are many unintended consequences. These are so numerous, that we have a taxonomy of EHR unintended consequences.
The EHR has also stifled consultant verbal communication. Why talk, it is in the chart?!?
Finally, the EHR has given us the millennial version of medical cheating: CoPaGA - Copy and Paste Gone Amok. This entails plagiarism of others notes and confirmation bias when erroneous information is carried forward without thought.
Are the holes winning?? It is a neck and neck race from my seat.
So, to bring this back around to osteopathic graduate medical education, it is our job as medical educators to keep the holes from lining up!!
We need to teach hand-off communication, both written and verbal. It needs to be taught formally and tested formally (I see an OSCE in your future).
We also need to teach how to use the EHR and the new professionalism that goes along with this tool. This is not typing 101. It is how to study and implement effective process changes. Another need is professional communication and the roles of each member of the healthcare team.
The alternative is 1 + 1 will equal zero, or, the will be many holes lining up in our Swiss cheese.
Showing posts with label ACOs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ACOs. Show all posts
Tuesday, August 16, 2011
Friday, July 8, 2011
Accountable Osteopathic Educational Organizations - AOEOs coming to a hospital near you!
So the buzz in the health care community right now is Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs). The concept is an entity that is accountable for the care of populations of patients. This entity encompasses hospitals, physicians, care management entities, home care, dialysis centers, etc., etc., etc. The overarching goal is that there is improved value (quality and cost) to the patient. There are multiple entities that are mentioned as shining examples of this model. Critics proclaim that this cannot be done broadly and that we should not even try.
Apart from, yet concomitant with this trend is the discussions in Washington about accountability in graduate medical education. This is coming, maybe sooner than we think.
Students of the game are well aware of the MedPAC report on the subject of accountability of Indirect Graduate Medical Education (IME) dollars. There was a New England Journal Opinion piece from MedPAC on the same topic. In addition, there was a front page article today in the Boston Globe discussing both decreases in GME funding from the Federal government and the lack of accountability in the current system.
What will accountability mean? It is any one's guess, but if I had to read the tea leaves I would start at the Quality Compare web site mentioned in a previous post. The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has laid the groundwork for what it sees as transparency here. It has also given a glimpse of the clinical metrics that it intends to use in the future in recent rules and proposed rules regarding Value-Based Purchasing (VBP). The OGME world can expect educational metrics in the not-so-distant future.
Specifically, expect to see: program size, program retention, board pass rates, graduates that practice in under served areas, graduates that practice within 25 miles of the training site, graduates of internal medicine and pediatrics programs that practice primary care.
Secondary, one may see: does the hospital have an EHR, how much of the training is ambulatory, what are the procedure rates when applicable, is there training directly with other types of providers?
A next level may be: continuous certification results for graduates, VBP results like HbA1C, LDL cholesterol, ACE inhibitors for CHF, etc. for graduates, state board of medicine actions for graduates. Maybe I'm stretching, maybe I'm not. If you were looking for a doctor, wouldn't you want to know how the program where he trained performs. And by performs, you wouldn't really care how big the library is...would you??
The list is endless. VBP is approaching 100 inpatient and outpatient measures, so, while I am being provocative, I am not wildly outside the box.
One additional note is that most of the VBP metrics have been vetted by and endorsed by the National Quality Forum. There have been calls for a similar group for GME metrics. It will be critical that OGME is represented at that table.
Change is coming! It will make the present discussions look quite petty. Are we ready??
Apart from, yet concomitant with this trend is the discussions in Washington about accountability in graduate medical education. This is coming, maybe sooner than we think.
Students of the game are well aware of the MedPAC report on the subject of accountability of Indirect Graduate Medical Education (IME) dollars. There was a New England Journal Opinion piece from MedPAC on the same topic. In addition, there was a front page article today in the Boston Globe discussing both decreases in GME funding from the Federal government and the lack of accountability in the current system.
What will accountability mean? It is any one's guess, but if I had to read the tea leaves I would start at the Quality Compare web site mentioned in a previous post. The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has laid the groundwork for what it sees as transparency here. It has also given a glimpse of the clinical metrics that it intends to use in the future in recent rules and proposed rules regarding Value-Based Purchasing (VBP). The OGME world can expect educational metrics in the not-so-distant future.
Specifically, expect to see: program size, program retention, board pass rates, graduates that practice in under served areas, graduates that practice within 25 miles of the training site, graduates of internal medicine and pediatrics programs that practice primary care.
Secondary, one may see: does the hospital have an EHR, how much of the training is ambulatory, what are the procedure rates when applicable, is there training directly with other types of providers?
A next level may be: continuous certification results for graduates, VBP results like HbA1C, LDL cholesterol, ACE inhibitors for CHF, etc. for graduates, state board of medicine actions for graduates. Maybe I'm stretching, maybe I'm not. If you were looking for a doctor, wouldn't you want to know how the program where he trained performs. And by performs, you wouldn't really care how big the library is...would you??
The list is endless. VBP is approaching 100 inpatient and outpatient measures, so, while I am being provocative, I am not wildly outside the box.
One additional note is that most of the VBP metrics have been vetted by and endorsed by the National Quality Forum. There have been calls for a similar group for GME metrics. It will be critical that OGME is represented at that table.
Change is coming! It will make the present discussions look quite petty. Are we ready??
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)