Showing posts with label ACGME. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ACGME. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 30, 2014

The Sword of Damocles, Redux

It has been some time (two years) since I last posted in this forum.  I wanted to share comments published recently in the POMA Newsletter.


The title of April’s Another Voice, “ACGME Sword of Damocles Poised to Strike a Devastating Blow”(POMA Newsletter, April 10, 2014), well describes the current state for osteopathic graduate medical education (OGME), but not for the reasons the author intends.  Please see the link to the meaning of the legend of Damocles’ sword.

One reason for my support for moving to a unified accreditation system is that the OGME system currently exists in a state “of foreboding engendered by a precarious situation, especially one in which the onset of tragedy is restrained only by a delicate trigger or chance.”  In the current state, multiple swords hang over OGME.  These include:  graduate medical education (GME) financing, governance of OGME by a membership organization, lack of reliability, relevance to graduates of colleges of osteopathic medicine (COM), lack of positions for future COM graduates, and yes, the actions of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME), who is the provider of the majority of GME for COM graduates.  A unified system removes many of these swords hanging “from a single horse hair” above the head of OGME.  Other swords may remain, but they are better tethered.  I’m confident that these can be removed by the future educational leadership of the osteopathic profession having a governance stake in GME within the United States.

Reliance on the status quo leaves all swords hanging over OGME’s head.  While I do not possess a crystal ball, I believe that one or more of the noted swords will fall within the not-too-distant future.  This would result in a GME system where the osteopathic profession has no governance stake.  If that happens, there will be no opportunity to teach osteopathic philosophy.  This would guarantee the fulfillment of Still’s admonition:  “unless you teach, neither you, nor osteopathic medicine will survive.”

It is a false interpretation that a unified system with shared governance precludes teaching osteopathic philosophy and tenets.  In fact, the unified system perpetuates osteopathic principles by explicitly including them in the accreditation standards.  One has to ask themselves:  is it more likely to have osteopathic philosophy taught in a system where the osteopathic profession shares a governance stake or a system where the osteopathic profession has no governance stake?  I recognize that all do not share my concern for the swords hanging over our heads which are “poised to strike a devastating blow.”  They would say that the status quo is acceptable and a full governance stake in a fraction of GME is preferable to shared governance of entire United States GME system.  I addressed this topic in the April JAOA.

The professional exploration of this topic is quite valuable.  The scientific method stipulates that the first step in any evaluation is to define the question.  This question is not the worth of osteopathic values.  The question is:  what is the most likely path to ensure that those values continue to be taught?  The evidence points to a unified system of GME accreditation being the answer.

Originally published in the POMA Newsletter, April 25, 2014

Monday, March 5, 2012

Everything flows...nothing stands still

I had the honor to represent the AODME this past week at the AOA’s Midyear Board of Trustees meeting.  On Friday, I delivered a brief review of issues and happenings in OGME and the AODME.  I will share them with you here, in a somewhat expanded outline form.  Over the next few months, I hope to expand on several of the topics.
I have noted the Greek philosopher Heraclitus previously.  He is the one who noted that nothing endures but change.   In the same breath, he also noted that “everything flows” and that “nothing stands still.”  This latter two points probably sum up well Graduate Medical Education in the United States and OGME in particular.
Recent flow can be highlighted in three areas:  operational/accreditation, financial and structural.
Operational/accreditation
·         The “new” AOA program standards in many specialties and new crosswalks have been in play for several months now.  Early feedback from programs, OPTIs and the November PTRC meeting were generally positive.  More change is coming in this area in the form of institutional accreditation.  This is new to AOA programs and the devil will be in the details of implementation.
·         The AOA match has come and gone.  While the match statistics are interesting (and pontification on their meaning is an annual early February topic much like Punxsutawny Phil’s shadow), “matching” for osteopathic programs is a 5 part process – AOA match, scramble, wait, NRMP match and finally another scramble.  The wait until the final process is delayed this year by SOAP – not what you wash one washes their hands with – by the Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program of the NRMP.  The structured scramble.  The uncertainty for OGME is that unmatched DO students are bound to SOAP prior to scrambling “back” to OGME programs.  The impact remains to be seen, but many osteopathic DMEs and program directors are rightfully concerned.
·         The final area of uncertainty comes from the proposed ACGME rule that would require AGCME training as a prerequisite for further ACGME training.  ** I purposefully linked to a Google search for "ACGME proposed rule" here so you can see the reaction yourself. **  blOGME has previously highlighted the details.  It seems clear that the proposed rule will have some impact on current students given anecdotal reports from the field.  The AOA and the ACGME are meeting on the topic of collaboration.  I am honored to be part of those deliberations.  If readers have not yet viewed ACGME CEO Tom Nasca’s piece in the New England Journal of Medicine on the Next Accreditation System (NAS) they should do so ASAP.
That is probably enough to keep one busy for now.  I will follow-up on the other two topics in the coming week.

Saturday, November 26, 2011

Thanksgiving, a time for reflection.

It seems that for many, Thanksgiving is a time for reflection.  There are many things, some personal - some collective, for which to give thanks.  In the spirit of reflection, I'd like to give some updates on past posts and see where we are now in the OGME worlds.

It has been some time since my last post!  I was hit by the confluence of MBA residency, two sons and a daughter headed back to school and the realities of a turn in my professional life.  But, enough about me...I'm back for now!

In an earlier post, I noted that there were a multitude of AOA standard's changes up for comment.  These included the changes to the standards for Osteopathic Postgraduate Training Institutions (OPTIs).  This were subsequently approved by the AOA's Council on Postgraduate Training (COPT) at their November meeting.  There, for better or for worse, were few comments.  While I'm sure that some will come back and wonder the who, why, when and where of these standards changes, little can be said about the transparency of the process.

I have noted several times that I participated in a conference on the future of graduate medical education in the United States in May.  This was sponsored by the Macy Foundation.  The report from this conference was published online and the monograph has been printed.  There has been quite a bit of discussion in both the lay press and the medical media on this report.  The Federal government's Council on Graduate Medical Education discussed this at their most recent meeting.

In October the ACGME published proposed changes to their Common Program Requirements.  The changes would require ACGME (or Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada) accredited training as a prerequisite for further ACGME training.  This would significant alter several ACGME residency programs' practices, such as Family Medicine, Radiology and Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation residencies.  It would also significantly impact fellowships in several specialties.

These changes have several potential unintended consequences to GME and physician workforce.  There are also several direct consequences to osteopathic trainees.  The changes included an impact statement that tangentially questioned the veracity of AOA accreditation of GME.  The AODME along with the AOA and AACOM submitted comments on the proposed changes.  Many other organizations, both within and outside the osteopathic community also commented on the proposals negative impact on osteopathic physicians.  We all eagerly await the outcome.

As the end of the year holidays come upon us, the AODME has published for approval changes to the organization's by-laws.  These changes, which I will discuss in a subsequent post, aim to update the by-laws and the AODME to be in line with the current realities of OGME.

Finally, in a weekend of thanks, I am thankful most for my family.  Thanksgiving weekend is always a joy to spend time with my immediate and extended family.  I am especially thankful for Ava, Ben, Ethan and Michele!  They keep me going through thick and thin!