Showing posts with label Feedback. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Feedback. Show all posts

Thursday, April 5, 2012

Who wants to live forever?!?!

On a recent flight across the United States, a familiar song played on my iPod, Queen’s Who Wants to Live Forever.  While the song clearly asks a question about mortality and immortality, that question has two derivations.  The two questions are:
1.       Who wants to win the prize of immortality?
2.       Why would anyone want to live forever?
Some further context may help.  The song was written and performed by Queen for the movie Highlander.  The movie follows Connor MacLeod who was born in 1518 in Glenfinnan near the shores of Loch Shiel.  He is one of Earth’s immortals who fight for the ultimate prize of omniscience.  The person who wins the prize must behead all of the other immortals on the planet.  As each immortal succumbs, the victor gains the strength of the fallen.  That sounds pretty simple, thus, who wants the prize?  Who wants to live forever?
The problem is that Connor does not always like being immortal.  In the movie’s opening scene he is almost killed in battle by another immortal in a Scottish clan skirmish.  Just as he is to be beheaded his clansmen stop the rival – the Kurgan.  Connor, who will surely die, is taken back to Glenfinnan, but inexplicably lives.  It is now his clan that wants him dead figuring that he must be possessed by the devil.  He is eventually banished from the village.  After this he meets a woman, Heather, who becomes his wife.  He cannot have children, he’s immortal, and this is a lifelong sorrow for he and Heather.  Worse, Heather grows old over the years and he does not.  She eventually dies in his arms.  He learns that immortals should have transient bonds.  So, why would anyone really want to live forever?
OK, now you are asking what this has to do with OGME.  Well, there was a recent article in the Wall Street Journal entitled "Why Doctors Die Differently."  The article reported on the differences between physician’s end of life decisions versus those of the general public.  There were some striking differences.  Who wants to live forever?  Physicians were more likely to choose conservative and palliative management when faced with low cure or survival rates.  The question posed is whether physicians unique perspective, they clearly have both knowledge and experience dealing with end of life issues and watching other people die, changes their view of the question.  To the general public, the prize is immortality.  The medical community – doctors, nurses, researchers, pharmaceutical companies – has been in search of this prize since the beginning of time.  Clearly that resonates with the public – why else would they be willing to pay so much for so little?
Some may say that medicine hasn’t furthered the immortality notion.  Think for a second though about Queen’s voice Freddie Mercury.  Freddie died far too young of AIDS.  All one has to do is watch a Queen concert on YouTube and they will see one of the most alive people ever known.  Freddie could command entire stadiums across two continents (as he did at Live Aid).  Listening to him sing Who Wants to Live Forever and another poignant song, The Show Must Go On, make me wonder what his view of certain death must have been.  He contracted HIV in the late 1980s and died in the early 1990s.  Everyone who got HIV at that time died of AIDS or an AIDS associated illness.  We all know, Magic Johnson knows quite well, that that doesn’t happen now, at least in the “developed” world.  HIV is only one death sentence that has been pardoned.  There are many more each year.
They lesson for physicians, physicians in training and physicians that train physicians is that the end of life is many times as important as life itself.  It is also important to share the lessons of our previous patients with our current patients.  It seems clear that physicians head those lessons when they make their own decisions regarding death and dying.  We need to ask patient both:
1.       Do you want us to do everything to make you better?
2.       Are you sure that you would like to suffer more?
The answers are a matter of perspective…

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Feedback is good!

Feedback is good!  Yet all to often, we are reticent to provide feedback to our colleagues, our trainees and ourselves.

There is a large body of research that suggests that one of the key drivers of human behavior is feedback.  This feedback may come from within - completing a task and gaining satisfaction from the completion - or from without - a faculty member/program director/DME providing feedback to a trainee.  How this latter feedback is delivered is critical as destructive feedback can do much damage.

The AODME recently received feedback on the 2011 joint Annual Meeting with AACOM.  This feedback was all GOOD!!!  That is not to say there there were not both positive and negative comments - there were both - but the simple task of attendees taking the time to honestly comment and the review by both the program committee and individual faculty members is nothing but GOOD.  Over the years, I have learned from playing both roles - program planner and faculty member.

As a program planner, it is clear that our members want interactive sessions that provide practical information on how to perform their daily job.  As DMEs one is an educator, leader, manager, human resource specialist, counselor, marketer and cheerleader all wrapped up in to one.  The AODME needs to provide support for all of these roles.  There is also a need to inform our members of how outside agencies and outside regulations impact their jobs.  Members are also quite sensitive to extreme opinions on topics.  Those appear to be better received when they are balanced by a panel of varied views.

As an individual, I relish the feedback to help me improve.  Generally individuals flow right to the negative comments.  The second reaction is usually defensive.  Once one gets past these knee-jerk tendencies, the real meat of personal improvement ensues.  Willie Stargell (I'm a Pirates' fan and Willie was the captain in 1979 when they last won the World Series) said:  "I eventually became proud of my strikeouts, because each one represented another learning experience."  One of my personal shortcomings is the use of acronyms - alphabet soup.  I have set a goal to work on this.  Thanks for the tip!!  I received a curious comment several years ago, someone in the audience interpreted an aviation reference that I used regarding Tenerife and patient safety as all wrong.  This person was a pilot.  I missed the point.  I subsequently improved the delivery.  Thanks again!!  I used a reference to ACGME DIO's that there were not degree requirements.  I said that one didn't "even need a high school diploma."  My point was that the ACGME has an open process.  My comment though was perceived as condescending.  I appreciate the perspective - thanks!  I'm always reminded that we all touch a different part of the elephant!

The bottom line is that each comment has helped me grow.  We never stop learning!

The bottom line...generous amounts of collegial, professional feedback is one of the greatest learning tools we have.